Desserts, Smoothies, Shakes and Malts
Fountain Favorites
Take a sentimental journey to the good old days with our Eveready Floats and Sodas made with real premium ice cream-
Brooklyn Egg Cream
Nobody makes it like the Eveready
$4.49
-
Black Cow
Old fashioned root beer float
$5.99
-
Brown Cow
A classic cola float
$5.99
-
Black and Brown Cow
Root beer float and chocolate syrup
$5.99
-
Ice Cream Soda
A big scoop of ice cream perched on a glass of sparkling flavored soda topped with whipped cream and a cherry. Your choice of vanilla, chocolate, cherry, raspberry, mocha or strawberry
$5.99
Smoothies, Shakes & Malts
-
Yogurt Smoothies
Pineapple, bananas and greek yogurt $6.99
Strawberries, bananas and greek yogurt $6.99
Blueberries, bananas and greek yogurt $6.99
-
Malts
$6.49
-
Shakes
Your choice of: Chocolate, vanilla, Oreo®, strawberry, raspberry, pineapple, orange, fresh banana, strawberry-banana
$6.49
Sundae Favorites
-
Original Hot Fudge Sundae
Three scoops of premium vanilla ice cream smothered with steaming hot fudge topped with chopped nuts, chocolate chips, whipped cream, and a cherry
$6.99
-
Oreo® Cookie Avalanche
Three Scoops of cookies and cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and Oreo® cookies
$6.99
-
Monkey Business
Classic banana split Eveready style. Fresh ripe banana, vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry ice cream smothered with pineapple, strawberry, chocolate topping, whipped cream, chopped nuts, mini chocolate chips & a cherry
$7.49
-
Brownie Sundae
A giant fudge brownie topped with three scoops of vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, chopped nuts, whipped cream, and a cherry
$6.99
-
Scoupe De Ville
The Caddy of them all. Scoops of ALL our ice creams with hot fudge, bananas, nuts, strawberries and a cloud of whipped cream. It comes with two spoons!
$10.99
-
Candy Store Sundae
Three scoops of premium vanilla ice cream topped with Reeses Pieces®, M&M’s®, Heath Bar®, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry
$6.99
-
Big Eddy
Five scoops of our premium ice cream covered with strawberries, marshmallows and chocolate sauce. Then we top it off with a whole split banana, sprinkles, nuts, and whipped topping
$7.99
-
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
Your choice of ice cream sandwiched between two fresh-baked cookies with whipped cream
$6.99
Cakes & Cheesecakes
-
Death By Chocolate Cake
Three layers of the moistest, deepest, darkest chocolate cake you could eat
$8.95
-
Tiramisu
Our favorite here. A fluffy Italian custard cake made with espresso-soaked ladyfingers
$7.95
-
Strawberry Short Cake
Our own shortcake layered with strawberries and whipped cream
$8.50
-
Carrot Cake
An old-world favorite with a creamy cheese frosting
$8.95
-
Mouse Cake
Chocolate cake with chocolate mousse topped with a chocolate mousse mouse
$7.95
-
Original NY Cheesecake
World-famous! Irresistible!
$7.95
-
Strawberry Cheesecake
$8.95
-
Fudge Brownie Cheesecake
Rich cheesecake in a flaky crust topped with brownies & fudge
$8.95
-
Oreo® Cheesecake
Loaded with Oreo® cookies
$8.95
-
Cannoli Cheesecake
NY Cheesecake with chocolate chips and topped with cannoli cream and a mini cannoli
$8.95
-
Baklava Cheesecake
NY Cheesecake topped with Baklava made of Filo pastry layered with chopped nuts and honey
$8.95
Pastries, Pies and Puddings
-
Berry Tart
A buttery tart filled with vanilla custard and topped with seasonal berries
$8.50
-
Eclair
A classis chocolate eclair. Choux pastry filled with vanilla custard and topped with icing
$5.95
-
Cannoli
Two cannoli shells stuffed with cannoli cream
$5.49
-
Napoleon
Puff pastry layers with vanilla pastry cream and topped with a thin layer of vanilla and chocolate glaze
$7.95
-
Cream Puffs
Three large French Choux pastry balls filled with vanilla custard
$7.95
-
Black and White Cookie
$3.95
-
Apple Pie
$5.99
-
Cherry Pie
$5.99
-
Coconut Custard Pie
$5.99
-
Lemon Meringue Pie
$5.99
-
Rice Pudding
$5.49
-
Bread Pudding
$5.49